Showing posts with label subtraction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label subtraction. Show all posts

Thursday, May 21, 2015

Bamidbar- Reading, Comparing, and Calculating with large numbers

Note that the section of quotes from this week's parsha is quite long in order to show the context for Levite and firstborn census numbers. As always, I organize all of the information for you beginning below the quotes. If your time is short, feel free to scroll past the citations.
"Hashem spoke to Moshe in the Wilderness of Sinai, saying, 'Count the sons of Levi according to their fathers' house, according to their families, every male from one month of age and up shall you count them.' Moshe counted them according to the word of Hashem, as he had been commanded.
These were the sons of Levi, by their names: Gershon, Kohath, and Merari. These were the names of the sons of Gershon according to their families: Livni and Shimei. The sons of Kohath according to their families: Amram and Izhar, Hevron and Uzziel. The sons of Merari according to their families: Mahli and Mushi. These are the families of the Levites, according to their fathers' house.
For Gershon- the Livnite family and the Shimeite family; these are the Gershonite families- their counted ones according to the number of every male, from one month of age and up: their counted ones [were] seven thousand, five hundred." ~Bamidbar 3:14-22
"And for Kohath- the Amramite family, the Izharite family, the Hevronite family, and the Uzzielite family; these were the Kohathite families- the number of every male from one month of age and up [was] eight thousand, six hundred; the guardians of the charge of the sanctity." ~Bamidbar 3:27-28
"For Merari- the Mahlite family and the Mushite family; these were the Merarite families- their counted ones according to the number of every male from one month of age and up [was] six thousand, two hundred." ~Bamidbar 3:33-34
"All the counted ones of the Levites, which Moshe and Aaron counted by the word of Hashem according to their families, every male from one month of age and up, were twenty-two thousand.
Hashem said to Moshe, 'Count every firstborn male of the Children of Israel from one month of age and up, and take a census of their names. You shall take the Levites for Me- I am Hashem- in place of every firstborn of the Children of Israel, and the animals of the Levites in place of every firstborn of the animals of the Children of Israel.' Moshe counted- as Hashem had commanded him- every firstborn of the Children of Israel. Every firstborn male according to the number of their names, from one month of age and up, according to their countings, was twenty-two thousand, two hundred and seventy-three.
Hashem spoke to Moshe, saying, 'Take the Levites in place of every firstborn of the Children of Israel, and the animals of the Levites in place of their animals, and the Levites shall be Mine, I am Hashem. And as for those redeemed of [the firstborn], the two hundred and seventy-three of the firstborn of the Children of Israel who are in excess over the Levites, you shall take five shekels each according to the head count, in the sacred shekel shall you take; the shekel is twenty geirah. You shall give the money to Aaron and his sons, of those redeemed in excess among them.'" ~Bamidbar 3:39-48
In this week's parsha, we learn of multiple censuses that were taken in the desert. Last year, I looked at the census information for the 12 Israelite tribes. This census was taken for men from the age of 20 years old and older. In my post last year, I analyzed that information from a basic statistical averages viewpoint- exploring the mean, median, and mode for the data set of the census. 

This year, I would like to look at the census information for the Levites. Since we're dealing with a lot of information here, let's first focus and pull out the numerical information that we're trying to look at. The census information for the Levites is first broken down into smaller census numbers from the individual Levite families, and then summed up at the end. Then, following that information, there is another census of the firstborn Israelites. We will look at all of these sets of information.

Let's begin by weeding through the information above to organize the pertinent information that we need:
Gershon- 7,500 males from 1 month of age and older
Kohath- 8,600 males from 1 month of age and older
Merari- 6,200 males from 1 month of age and older

Then, the total sum listed for all Levites is 22,000 males from 1 month of age and older

Stop for a minute and test out this calculation. 

  • Does 7,500 + 8,600 + 6,200 = 22,000? In fact, it actually adds to 22,300. 
So what's going on here? Why does the Torah omit 300 Levites in it's calculation? Rashi on 3:39 deals with this exact question. He explains that the total number of Levites was needed in order to redeem the firstborn Israelites. For every 1 Levite, 1 firstborn Israelite would be redeemed. Rashi says that the 300 Levites who are not included in the total sum were actually firstborns, themselves, and therefore would not count towards being able to redeem other Israelite firstborns, since they would be redeeming themselves.

Let's look on further- We are told that the firstborn Israelite males from 1 month of age and older totaled 22,273. 

So, if we replace one-for-one each firstborn Israelite with a non-firstborn Levite, we have 22,273 firstborns & 22,000 Levites available for redeeming:
22,273 - 22,000 = 273

Now, it seems that we have 273 firstborns who do not have a Levite to redeem them. If we continue reading, though, we see that Hashem has told Moshe that there are, in fact, 273 firstborns "in excess" of the Levites, and these 273 should be redeemed by collecting 5 shekels per person for each of them and that money will go to the Kohanim. 

Some other thoughts & activities:
  • It my be interesting to compare the census for the Levites with the census of the rest of the Israelites that's listed in the first part of the parsha. In making a comparison of the numbers, it would be important to keep in mind that the census for the 12 Israelite tribes was taken from 20 years and older, while the Levite census was taken from 1 month and older. Even more so, what interesting findings do you see when comparing the numbers of the two groups?
  • An interesting discussion topic may be to think about whether there is a way to compare the information given for the general Israelite census to the firstborn Israelite census to figure out any further information regarding numbers of Israelites between certain ages? Is there enough information given to create comparisons of smaller age groups- either from each tribe or from the whole group?
  • For younger students, it might be interesting to just think about place value and reading large numbers. Students could have a matching activity in which they have to identify the numbers of the censuses and match them to the appropriate tribes. Students could also talk about how to think about comparing which numbers are larger and which numbers are smaller- place values and how you can use place values to compare numbers to each other to figure out which is larger and which is smaller. Students who catch on quickly to this concept could think about ordering the numbers from smallest to largest or largest to smallest.
  • Follow-up activity- values are given for how many shekels were collected for the 273 "excess" firstborns who did not have Levite redeemers (Bamidbar 3:50). Older students could check the calculations for the values to see if it matches the amount that they calculate should have been donated. We are also told (Bamidbar 3:47) that a shekel was worth 20 geirah. Students can calculate a conversion of the value to also figure out the value of the donation in geirahs. 

Thursday, April 23, 2015

Tazria/Metzora- Investigating Patterns in Doubling

In Vayikra 12:2-5 we learn about the Biblical periods of impurity after a woman gives birth. We learn that after giving birth to a son, she is impure for one week (7 days) and she may not touch holy items or partake in eating the terumah for an additional 33 days. At the end of the 40 day period (7 + 33 = 40), she brings sacrifices. After giving birth to a daughter, she is impure for 2 weeks (14 days) and she may not touch holy items or partake in eating the terumah for an additional 66 days. At the end of the 80 day period (14 + 66 = 80), she brings sacrifices.

Doubling Numbers & The Sums of Numbers:

If we look at the timeline for a woman's post-delivery impurity and offering of sacrifices, we can see that the timeline after the delivery of a daughter is double the timeline after the delivery of a son. Let's take a minute to break it down piece by piece:

Post delivery impurity:

Son- 1 week (7 days)
Daughter- 2 weeks (14 days)

Additional time before bringing sacrifices:

Son- 33 days
Daughter- 66 days

Total time post-delivery until sacrifices are brought:

Son- 7 days + 33 days = 40 days
Daughter- 14 days + 66 days = 80 days

As a teacher, I have seen students many times find a pattern in the way numbers work together and automatically assume that the pattern will apply to all numbers. Sometimes their assumption is correct and they have found an accurate pattern in number theory; other times students stumble upon a neat trick that works with specific types of numbers but cannot be extrapolated to other numbers. Without thinking about and testing their pattern, students may inadvertently apply a neat trick as a greater application in number theory. 


With this in mind, I propose the following investigation for students:

If you double two numbers, will the sum of the doubled numbers always be double the sum of the original numbers?  (Note that this investigation is applicable for students of any age who aren't yet certain of the answer and explanation of why.)

Students can test this by picking a variety of different numbers and checking what happens when they double the numbers and compare the sums of different numbers- original and then doubled. Students can work in partners or individually and compare their findings with their classmates. It's important for students to consider that, while they can't test every number, if enough numbers follow their pattern, they can feel confident that their pattern holds true for most numbers. 


With enough testing, students should develop the basic premise of the theorem:

If a + b = c, then 2a + 2b = 2c

Through their testing, at least some students (at least by grade 5+) should develop enough of a thought process about their testing to begin to explain why this is true.


Some follow-up investigations:

Math related-
*Does this hold true when you add more addends to your original addition statement? i.e. if you add three numbers, will the sum of double those 3 numbers be double the original sum? 4? 5? etc. Why?
*Does this hold true for subtracting numbers?
*Does this hold true for multiplication? division?
*Does this hold true for negative numbers? fractions & decimals?

The more scenarios and number sets that they test, the stronger theory they can develop for use in their future work.

Math & Parsha related-

*Specifically related to this week's parsha, when you convert 33 days and 66 days into time measured in weeks & days, will they still appear to be doubled at first glance? Can you explain your findings? Based on your findings, do you think there's a reason that the Torah may have listed the time periods in the way that they are listed?

Thursday, December 11, 2014

Vayeishev- Timeline and basic arithmetic related activity ideas

"Then Jacob rent his garments and placed sackcloth on his loins; he mourned for his son many days." ~Bereishit 37;34
This week we learn of when Joseph's brothers sold him and implied to Jacob, their father, that he was attacked and killed by a wild animal. Upon seeing Joseph's bloody tunic and surmising his death, we are told that Jacob mourned for "many days". Rashi  here explains that "many days" actually means that he mourned for Joseph the entire time that Joseph was missing to him- which actually calculated to be 22 years.

Activity Connections:
Activity ideas in increasing conceptual difficulty:
  • The most basic calculation connection would be to begin with the statement 1) in Bereishit 37;2 (at the start of this week's parsha) that Joseph was 17 years old at the time of the story of his sale and 2) in Bereishit 41;46 (in next week's parsha- Miketz) that Joseph was 30 years old at the time that he first was called to come before Pharoah. Younger students can just calculate the passage of time between Joseph's sale and his appearance before Pharoah. Before learning subtraction, this could be drawn on a time line for students where they can physically count the years. Children who are a little older can count up from 17 to 30 or subtract 30-17.
  • The next step would be to look at the calculation that is offered by Rashi regarding the 22 years that pass before Jacob sees Joseph again. Children can take the calculation from the activity above and pull out (from Parshat Miketz) the additional years that passed- 7 plentiful years followed by 2 years of famine before Jacob travels to Egypt. Students would then add the 3 numbers together to confirm that the time that passed was truly 22 years.
  • A larger activity, which could be leveled in many ways depending on the age and abilities of students, would be to pull out the information from larger segments of Sefer Bereishit and place the information onto a more comprehensive timeline. Students could either create timelines for individual sections, or a more comprehensive timeline that incorporates multiple people's storylines for students to see the crossover of time between the different stories that we are given throughout Sefer Bereishit. Along with Rashi's interpretations and explanations throughout the sefer, students can use their own calculations for comparison of information and calculating where everything that we learn would actually fall on a grand-scale timeline.
We can use the information given in this week's parsha and next week's parsha to analyze the passage of time that Rashi refers to on Bereishit 37;24. Creating a timeline helps students formulate an understanding of the chronology of events, which provides them a framework for the both the logical progression of events and the greater picture of how multiple events fit together with each other. In addition to the sequential understanding that is gained, students also practice basic addition and subtraction by calculating the time lapses between different events. Students also work on identifying which information needs to be added or subtracted in order to find missing information, which is a critical problem solving skill. Finally, when the completed timeline has been pieced together, students can look to compare and contrast information to gain a deeper insight that they may not have picked up on in their original, single-story understanding of the events.

Thursday, July 3, 2014

Balak- Mathematical Insights Using Percentages and Other Basic Math

"These are the counted ones that Moses, Aaron, and the princes of Israel counted- twelve men, one man for his father's house, were they- these were all the counted ones of the Children of Israel, according to their fathers' house, from twenty years of age and up, everyone who goes out to the army in Israel: All their counted ones were six hundred and three thousand, five hundred and fifty. The Levites according to their fathers' tribe were not counted among them." ~Bamidbar 1;44-47 (Parshat Bamidbar)

In this week's parsha, following the plague as punishment for Israel becoming attached to Baal-peor:
"Hashem said to Moses, 'Take all the leaders of the people, and hang [the idol worshipers] before Hashem  opposite the sun- and the flaring wrath of Hashem will withdraw from Israel.' Moses said to the judges of Israel, 'Let each man kill his men who were attached to Baal-peor.'" ~Bamidbar 25;4-5
"Those who died in the plague were twenty-four thousand." ~Bamidbar 25;9

Rashi on Bamidbar 25;5 says:

Let each man kill his men: Each and every one of the judges of Israel would kill two and the judges of Israel were seven myriads (seventy thousand), and eight thousand as stated in Sanhedrin.

At first, Rashi's commentary confused me. At the end of the parsha, we are explicitly told that 24,000 died as the result of the plague. Rashi here is stating that 78,000 judges each killed 2 people. The numbers alone don't make sense- how did 78,000 judges kill only 24,000 people (comparing numbers- good lower elementary skill)? If we do the basic multiplication (middle elementary skill), to calculate Rashi's understanding that each judge killed 2 sinners, then 

78,000 Judges x 2 sinners killed = 156,000 men killed.

How does this make sense? I did a little more research, and it seems that Gemara Sanhedrin 82a talks about the Israelite man and the Midianite woman being Zimri son of Salu (from the tribe of Shimon) and Cozbi daughter of Zur (Midianite princess). In the gemara, it says that Zimri brought with him 24,000 Israelites from his tribe, which is what led him to sin (that's some peer pressure!). While it's not stated explicitly, my understanding from this explanation would then be that the 24,000 that we are told of in Bamidbar 25;9 are just the 24,000 Israelites from the tribe of Shimon, and that the additional sinners who were killed by the judges actually did number 156,000.

Now that we have some numbers to go on, let's work with some calculations:

*Let's start by figuring out how many people actually died all together as a result of this situation: (Good practice of long addition algorithm for younger students- remember to line up place values)

24,000 + 156,000 = 180,000 total Israelites who died 

*If we go based on these two accountings, how many Jews were left in the general population (non-Levite) after the plague? (Good practice of long subtraction algorithm for younger students- remember to line up place values)

603,550 - 180,000 = 423,550 total non-Levite Israelites who were left

*What percentage of the general population of Jews were killed in the plague? (Good calculation practice for Middle School)

Following our methods from Parshat Vayigash:
180,000/603,550 = 0.29823544031, or approximately 30%
This means that approximately 70% of the general population was left after the plague was finished. Let's check and see if those numbers are consistent:
423,550/603550 = 0.70176455968, or approximately 70%

An interesting follow-up activity:
If we are assuming that the 24,000 mentioned in Bamidbar 25;9 were all from Shimon, how would our percentage calculations look if we just took the census information for Shimon from back in Bamidbar and compared what percentage of Shimon died as a result of the plague. When making these calculations, we could also consider that Zimri was from Shimon and was killed, but not accounted for in the 24,000. Also, the Judges from Shimon each killed 2 people, so the Israelites from Shimon who were killed by the Shimonite judges would also need to be added into the Shimonite death toll for an accurate calculation.




Thursday, December 12, 2013

Vayechi- Some Basic Arithmetic

"Joseph dwelt in Egypt- he and his father's household- and Joseph lived one hundred and ten years. Joseph saw three generations through Ephraim; even the sons of Machir son of Manasseh were raised on Joseph's knees." ~Bereisit 50;22-23

Subtraction/Passing of Time:
In math, when trying to calculate the distance between two numbers, there are a couple of ways that students begin to work with the concept. Some students will begin by counting up from the lower number to the higher number, while keeping track of how many "steps" or numbers they pass as they count. Some students will use the same method, but count their "steps" backwards, moving from the higher number to the lower number. Ultimately, we want students to recognize that in order to calculate the distance between two numbers, the fastest calculation method is to take the higher number and subtract from it the lower number. Although calculation and "regrouping" with time can become more complex, this process works in exactly the same way to calculate passage of time; we take the later date, time, etc and subtract from it the earlier date, time, etc. Through this calculation, we can see how much time has passed between two identified time periods.

Note that I said "take the higher number and subtract from it the lower number" instead of the more direct "subtract the lower number from the higher number". This is because a common confusion among children occurs when you say "subtract" and then put the subtrahend (second number) before the minuend (first number).

Some numbers that we know about Joseph:
--We know from back in Parshat Vayeishev (Bereishit 37;3) that Joseph was 17 yrs old when his brothers threw him into the pit and he was sold and brought down to Egypt.
--We know from back in Parshat Miketz (Bereishit 31;45-46) that he was 30 yrs when Pharoah gave Joseph Poti-phera's daughter as a wife and made him viceroy of Egypt.
--We are now told that Joseph lived to be 110 yrs and lived to see three generations (see below for specifics).

Let's try out some questions that would just require basic calculation.
*How long had Joseph been living down in Egypt when he died?
To answer this, we need to subtract his age at his death minus his age when he was sold and went down to Egypt:
110 - 17 = 93; So, Joseph lived in Egypt for 93 years

*How long had Joseph been married when he died?
To answer this, we need to subtract his age at his death minus his age when he was married:
110 - 30 = 80; So, Joseph was married for 80 years

To add some complexity:
If we want to create a more complex problem for a higher level learner, we could ask them to think about some approximate ages of Joseph's generations given the information presented.

What we know here:
--Joseph's married life spanned 80 yrs (see our subtraction above)
--Joseph saw 3 generations of children through Ephraim (children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and great-great-grandchildren)

If all generations were spaced evenly, we could divide 80 ÷ 3 to tell us the approximate years between each generation. 80 ÷ 3 = 26.7; This would mean that every 26-27 years, a new generation was born. Let's count this up according to Joseph's comparable ages:
Joseph get's married= Joseph is 30 yrs old
Ephraim is born/Joseph becomes a father= Let's assume Joseph is 31 yrs old
Ephraim becomes a father/ Joseph becomes a grandfather= 31 + 26 = Joseph is 57 yrs old
Ephraim becomes a grandfather/ Joseph becomes a great-grandfather= 57 + 27 = Joseph is 84 yrs old
Ephraim becomes a great-grandfather/Joseph becomes a great-great-grandfather= 84 + 26 = 110